In a re/code article on Wednesday, John Paczkowski stated with conviction that iWatch will make its debut on September 9th, along with the new iPhone(s).
Within a day, there were a hundred stories reporting that bit of news — either citing John as the source or simply presenting it as fact. Computerworld actually ran the headline Apple makes Sept. 9 event official, hints at more than iPhone 6. Uh … not really. All Apple did was send out an invitation.
Now I happen to have a lot of respect for John, and he may well be right. Still, one can’t help but marvel at how quickly unverified stories spread.
Whether it’s true or not, this isn’t the kind of decision Apple makes lightly. It’s fun to imagine the two sides of the debate — do we launch these products in two separate events or combine them into one?
Since I wasn’t invited to the meeting, I’ll have this debate with myself.
We must have two events!
Ken, how dare you even think of combining two fantastic events? Have you lost your Apple senses?
How quickly you forget The Teachings Of Steve. “Thou shalt milk every new product for maximum buzz.” The whole world is anticipating the iPhone 6, grasping at every new rumor. The web will reverberate for weeks about this one event alone.
And then we’ll do it all again for iWatch. Two nuclear explosions for the price of one. Well, okay, we’ll spend twice as much, but you get my drift.
Lest you forget, no truly revolutionary product in Apple’s history has ever been launched alongside another. It’s a waste of marvel. Every great Apple product is launched in a spotlight, and that spotlight is only big enough for one.
Here’s something else to consider. You don’t need an iPhone to enjoy its built-in features or all the cool wrist-apps that will be available in the App Store. Present iPhone and iWatch together and you might create the false impression that iWatch is only for iPhone people. The iWatch market is vastly bigger than that.
Sit down, I’m not done with you.
How much money do you think people have to spend on all this i-stuff? The iWatch isn’t cheap. Is it realistic to get people digging into their pockets for an iPhone 6, and then, on the very same day, tell them they need to spend another $300-400 on the iWatch? There’s only so much cash we can squeeze out of them. Far smarter to get people fired up about iPhone 6, then hit them up a month later with iWatch.
We must have one event!
Ken, haven’t you ever played Blackjack? Don’t you know you’re never supposed to split a winning hand?
There are two big, juicy reasons to combine the iPhone and iWatch events. This would be the biggest event in Apple history, at a time when people have dared to question us. And — these are two products that are made to work together.
Like you just said, Apple has never combined two revolutionary products this way. So what. We will now stand Apple tradition on its head. This will be Tim’s blockbuster moment, forever etched in history. Can you not imagine the extraordinary buzz from one monster over-the-top event, three months before the holidays?
This is a case where the whole is absolutely greater than the sum of its parts. One earthshaking event has more value than two “typical” Apple events.
I can see it now: we get an hour’s worth of theatrics and demos for the new iPhone models, followed by the launch of Apple’s long-awaited “next revolution.” And then the kicker. Tim says: “You’ve seen the new iPhone. You’ve seen the fabulous new iWatch. Each is amazing on its own — but just wait till you see what they can do together.”
Get your head out of the past, Ken. Extraordinary times call for extraordinary measures.
Looking forward to Tuesday
There really is a decent argument on both sides. But now that I’ve talked it over with myself, I’m hoping John Paczkowski is right. One massive event would be amazing. All those “Apple doesn’t innovate” arguments would be banished forever. (Or a year, whichever comes first.)
The two products have a symbiotic relationship, and seeing them in action together would be super-compelling. I love the fact that this event is happening in the very spot where Macintosh and iMac were launched. Quite symbolic.