November, 2009


5
Nov 09

Lost in the laptop labyrinth

laptop_configs

Every PC company tries to make it easier for customers to buy their stuff. Unfortunately, there’s a lot more to it than streamlining the checkout process. The real problem is a nasty one, rooted deep in the corporate culture — and all seem powerless to fix it:

Their product lines are bloated to the extreme.

I’ve prepared this handy chart to illustrate the absurdity. This is a look at laptops only (it’s equally horrifying on the desktop side), as presented on each company’s website. Apple offers only three models. Dell weighs in with ten. And HP over-weighs in with 19. It hurt my fingers just to type them.

With Apple, you simply pick one of the three basic models, and then customize based on your needs. Why does this lesson in simplicity elude the monoliths of PC-dom? Because their companies are structured around separate groups that don’t communicate well with each other, each fighting for its own budget and its own survival.

I venture to say that PC customers would be a lot happier if their basic choices were simpler. (The model names are stupefying too, but let’s save that topic for a future post.) Once you have an obvious starting point, its vastly easier for a human being to commit.

Not only would customers be happier with fewer models, the computer companies would shave millions off their operating costs — when razor-thin margins are what’s gotten them into this mess in the first place. Streamlining their offerings would drastically cut spending on manufacturing and marketing.

By spewing models as they do, PC companies actually put more distance between themselves and their customers. They’d bond more deeply if they guided their customers down a well-lit path. The sad fact is, those battleships really are difficult to turn around.

Bookmark and Share

4
Nov 09

A big hand for Lee Clow

09CreativesLeeClow

He's been behind the most amazing work for decades

Lee Clow is stepping down as the leader of the Media Arts Lab at Chiat, which is the group devoted to Apple’s advertising. He will, of course, remain the global creative chief of Chiat and in that capacity will still be involved with Apple.

So let us not speak of Lee in the past tense. But absolutely, let’s take a moment to give him the huge credit he deserves for his devotion to Apple and undying love of great creative. He played a huge role in making Apple what it is today, and for setting what many companies see as the gold standard in advertising.

It was a dark time in 1997. So dark, Apple stock was more like kryptonite than the platinum it’s become. Every day, there were more takeover rumors. Steve Jobs had just returned from exile and regained control of the company. First order of business on the marketing side was to blow up the agency review process that his predecessor had started. No time for that. Life signs were dangerously faint. Steve narrowed the choices to Chiat  in LA (his old agency when Macintosh was born) and Arnold in Boston (VW’s old agency, who had wowed Steve with a very cool video). Chiat won.

It would be folly to suggest that Lee didn’t see this as a great business opportunity. But if ever there was a moment of pure passion in the ad biz, this was it. Lee was driven by his love of Apple, his respect for Steve and the opportunity to re-create the magic of the birth of the Mac.

Lee’s talent, as it has been for decades, is to create defining moments for a variety of clients, including Nike and Nissan. That’s exactly what he’s done with Apple. It’s Lee who enlists and discovers the most amazing people, and let’s them do what they’re capable of. Once or twice you might say it’s a fluke. Year after year, for over 30 years, not so much.

So let all Apple enthusiasts appreciate what this man has done. From Apple II to Macintosh to iMac, iPod and iPhone, Lee’s been there every step of the way. And now he’s stepping back. Duncan Milner is officially taking over the day-to-day executive creative duties at Media Arts. Knowing him well, I can assure you that this jewel of advertising is in very good hands. Thanks Lee, and godspeed Duncan.

Bookmark and Share

3
Nov 09

I’ve got a crush on Cliq

Just when I thought I was losing my ability to love, comes this spot for Motorola’s new smartphone, the Cliq. Or is it the “Motorola Cliq with Motoblur”? Well, no matter how many syllables they throw my way, I’m sticking to my guns: I love this commercial.

The Cliq’s special power is that it merges contact lists, photos and social networking — Facebook, MySpace and Twitter — into one visual display. Not a bad concept for a phone. And a terrifically good concept for an ad.

In this spot, our hero stands alone in a desolate landscape with his Cliq. We then see his entire, mad, out-of-control world of contacts rushing to meet him — while he’s able to focus on the one contact he’s most interested in at the moment. The girl.

The idea is simple. But everyone who’s tried to turn a simple idea into something special knows how impossible it can be. In this case, they did everything perfectly. The acting is understated and natural. No one tries too hard (except for the wild hordes, but that’s what hordes are supposed to do). The girl gets one damn word, and it’s one of the most charming bits of dialog I’ve ever seen. It’s all in the body language.

But most of the magic is in the production. This could have been filmed a hundred different ways: in a different landscape, with different kinds of people, with different degrees of energy. And the editing could have gone a hundred ways as well. What we get is a frantic cast of thousands, dangerously fun action, with truly hilarious choices in depicting our hero’s “social network.” There’s an artful balance of high energy and dead quiet.

And, lest we forget, every bit of this action is devoted to delivering on the concept. Cliq’s reason for being is hard to miss.

Now let’s return to reality. iPhone became a juggernaut because it raised the bar by an order of magnitude. It’s hard to imagine any company outdoing iPhone by the same margin anytime soon. So the immediate goal is to simply take some wind out of iPhone’s sails. It’s too early to tell if Cliq is the phone to do that, or if future ads will be as good as this one. But I can’t watch this spot enough times. A big thank-you to everyone involved. (If anyone has the credits, please let me know.)

Bookmark and Share